Jay Cheel

Films rated
1,093since 2008
Average rating
3.5out of 5
Perfect scores
1665 out of 5
Off the scale
106 out of 5 or more

How Jay rates

Stars given. Older 4-star ratings are scaled to 5.
Show as a table
RatingFilmsShare
0 stars61%
0.5 stars262%
1 stars131%
1.5 stars383%
2 stars706%
2.5 stars11210%
3 stars13312%
3.5 stars13012%
4 stars24022%
4.5 stars14914%
5 stars16615%
6 out of 5101%

Off the scale

Films Jay gave more than 5 stars.

Loved it more

Where Jay rated a film furthest above the other hosts.

  1. Escape PlanJay ★★★★★ vs others 1.9
  2. Phobe: The Xenophobic ExperimentsJay ★★★★★ vs others 2.3
  3. Non-StopJay ★★★★★ vs others 2.2
  4. ImmortalsJay ★★★★★ vs others 2.3
  5. The Karate KidJay ★★★★★ vs others 1.7
  6. Marcel the Shell with Shoes OnJay ★★★★★ vs others 2.5
  7. Teenage Mutant Ninja TurtlesJay ★★★★★ vs others 1.9
  8. After EarthJay ★★★★★ vs others 1.9

Liked it less

Where Jay rated a film furthest below the other hosts.

  1. Deadpool & WolverineJay ★★★★★ vs others 3.3
  2. MorbiusJay ★★★★★ vs others 3.5
  3. Nightmare AlleyJay ★★★★★ vs others 3.0
  4. FlightJay ★★★★★ vs others 3.5
  5. After the HuntJay ★★★★★ vs others 2.8
  6. Barb and Star Go to Vista Del MarJay ★★★★★ vs others 3.5
  7. The Great WallJay ★★★★★ vs others 2.8
  8. Ender's GameJay ★★★★★ vs others 2.9

Harshest

Jay's lowest scores.

  1. Mr. Nobody★★★★★ Jul 27, 2026
  2. After the Hunt★★★★★ Dec 2, 2025
  3. Deadpool & Wolverine★★★★★ Jul 31, 2024
  4. Nightmare Alley★★★★★ Feb 2, 2022
  5. Dumb and Dumber To★★★★ Nov 17, 2014
  6. The House Bunny★★★★ Aug 24, 2008
  7. Flight Risk★★★★★ Feb 18, 2025
  8. Ready Player One★★★★★ Mar 12, 2024
  9. Morbius★★★★★ Apr 1, 2022
  10. Free Guy★★★★★ Oct 5, 2021

Perfect scores

Every film Jay gave full marks, newest first. Browse all their ratings